When you turn 50, the AARP offers start arriving in the mail. Among the travel discounts and insurance offers is the AARP® Essential Rewards Mastercard® from Barclays.
It has the trusted AARP logo on the front. It promises cash back on gas and drugstores. It seems like the obvious choice for a retiree.
But is it actually the best choice for your wallet?
As your trusted advocate, we believe in testing brand names against the math. We compared the AARP card head-to-head with a standard, top-rated cash back card (the Citi Double Cash®) to see which one actually puts more money in your pocket.
The answer might surprise you: The AARP card is excellent for medical bills, but it loses on almost everything else.
Key Takeaways
- The Specialist: The AARP card wins big on Medical Expenses (3% back), a category almost no other card covers.
- The Generalist: A standard 2% flat-rate card (like Citi Double Cash) wins on everyday spending like utilities, insurance premiums, and retail.
- The Verdict: The AARP card is a fantastic secondary card for healthcare costs, but it shouldn’t be your only card.
- The Donation Perk: Using the AARP card automatically donates to the AARP Foundation, which is a nice charitable bonus.
The Challenger: AARP® Essential Rewards Mastercard®
This card is custom-built for the specific spending habits of seniors, focusing heavily on health and travel necessities.
- Annual Fee: $0
-
Rewards Structure:
- 3% Cash Back on Gas and Drugstore purchases (excluding big-box stores like Target and Walmart).
- 2% Cash Back on eligible Medical Expenses (this includes doctors, hospitals, dentists, optometrists, and even some medical equipment).
- 1% Cash Back on all other purchases.
The “Superpower”: The 2% on Medical Expenses is unique in the credit card world. Most cards categorize medical bills as “general spending” and only give you 1% back. If you are facing high out-of-pocket costs for things like dental implants, hearing aids, or ongoing specialist visits, this card is a powerhouse that can put serious money back in your pocket.
The Champion: Citi Double Cash® Card
This is the gold standard for “simple” cash back, designed for people who want maximum value without thinking about categories.
- Annual Fee: $0
-
Rewards Structure:
- 2% Cash Back on everything. The structure is unique: you earn an unlimited 1% cash back when you make a purchase, and an additional 1% cash back as you pay for those purchases.
- No categories to track, no caps on earnings, and no quarterly activation required.
The “Superpower”: It pays 2% on the “boring stuff” — utilities, insurance premiums, home repairs, new furniture, and car maintenance — where the AARP card only pays 1%. Since these “boring” categories often make up the bulk of a senior’s budget, the Double Cash often comes out ahead in total dollars earned at the end of the year.
Head-to-Head Math: Who Earns More?
Let’s look at a typical monthly budget for a retired couple to see who wins.
|
Monthly Expense
|
Cost
|
AARP Card Earnings
|
Citi Double Cash Earnings
|
Winner
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Gas
|
$150
|
$4.50 (3%)
|
$3.00 (2%)
|
AARP
|
|
Prescriptions
|
$100
|
$3.00 (3%)
|
$2.00 (2%)
|
AARP
|
|
Doctor/Medical
|
$200
|
$4.00 (2%)
|
$4.00 (2%)
|
Tie
|
|
Groceries
|
$500
|
$5.00 (1%)
|
$10.00 (2%)
|
Citi
|
|
Utilities/Bills
|
$400
|
$4.00 (1%)
|
$8.00 (2%)
|
Citi
|
|
General Shopping
|
$300
|
$3.00 (1%)
|
$6.00 (2%)
|
Citi
|
|
TOTAL CASH BACK
|
--
|
$23.50
|
$33.00
|
CITI WINS
|
The Verdict: For a general budget, the Citi Double Cash earned 40% more cash back because it rewards the “boring” bills that make up most of your spending.
When Should You Get the AARP Card?
We still recommend the AARP card, but only for a specific type of user.
Get the AARP Card IF:
- You have high medical bills (e.g., upcoming surgery, dental work, or hearing aids).
- You drive a lot (road trips) and want the 3% gas reward.
- You want to support the AARP Foundation with every swipe.
Get a Flat 2% Card (like Citi or SoFi) IF:
- You want one single card for everything.
- Your biggest expenses are groceries, utilities, and shopping.
- You don’t want to think about “categories.”
Top Picks: The Best "General" Cash Back Cards
If you decide the AARP card is too limiting, here are the best no-fee alternatives. We selected these because they simplify your wallet while maximizing your return.
Quick Comparison: Top General Cash Back Cards
|
Card Name
|
Best For
|
Rewards
|
Annual Fee
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
SoFi Unlimited 2%
|
Zero Fees
|
Flat 2% on everything
|
$0
|
|
Capital One Quicksilver
|
Travel
|
Flat 1.5% + No Foreign Fees
|
$0
|
|
Citi Double Cash®
|
Simplicity
|
1% on buy + 1% on pay
|
$0
|
1. Best for Zero Fees: SoFi Unlimited 2% Credit Card — Sagewise Rating: 5.0
- Why: Like Citi, it earns a flat 2%. But SoFi goes a step further by having No Foreign Transaction Fees, making it a better choice if you travel internationally. It also includes $0 fraud liability, ensuring your retirement savings are safe. Check Rates at SoFi
2. Best for Simplicity: Citi Double Cash® Card — Sagewise Rating: 5.0
- Why: It earns 2% on every purchase, period. There are no caps and no categories. It is the perfect “set it and forget it” card for seniors who want to earn rewards on bills and insurance premiums without doing any math. Check Rates at Citi
3. Best for Travel Protection: Capital One Quicksilver Cash Rewards — Sagewise Rating: 4.5
- Why: While it earns slightly less (1.5%), it is a powerhouse for travelers. It has No Foreign Transaction Fees (saving you 3% abroad) and an incredibly easy-to-use app for tracking spending. Check Rates at Capital One
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
No, actually. While it is branded for AARP, anyone can apply for the card. However, you might not get the full “charitable donation” benefit if you aren’t a member.
No. It is a $0 annual fee card, which is one of its best features.
No. Insurance premiums (like Medicare Part B or supplemental plan premiums) usually do not count as “Medical Expenses” for rewards categories. They typically earn the base 1% rate. This is why a 2% flat-rate card is often better for paying insurance bills.
Yes! This is the smartest strategy. Use the AARP Card for your gas, pharmacy runs, and doctor co-pays. Use the Citi Double Cash for your groceries, utilities, and everything else. This way, you never earn less than 2%.
Barclays is a major international bank with solid customer service, though some seniors prefer the US-based, 24/7 support offered by Discover or American Express.
Find the Best Credit Card Rates (Compare the top cash back cards side-by-side.)
